NAPA reports the House’s 295 to 128 passage of the bill that would let 403(b) plans invest in collective investment trusts, closing the securities-law gap SECURE 2.0 left when it amended the tax code but not the securities laws. Proponents argue collective trusts carry lower fees than the mutual funds and annuities most 403(b) menus hold. Representative Lynch objected that the change trades investor protections for cost. In the Senate, companion S. 424 has picked up 20 additional cosponsors, eight of them Democrats.
Friday, November 13, 2026
№ 95Retirement Plans (13)·Health & Welfare (10)·Leave & Time Off (3)·Court Decisions & Case Commentary (8)·Executive Compensation (3)·Also Noteworthy (2)
The One Thing
Winning part of a retirement-plan lawsuit doesn’t settle who pays the legal bill. Participants in the Trader Joe’s case won about $1.19 million, including interest, on their recordkeeping-fee claim but lost on other claims. Their lawyers now seek about $2.93 million in fees, plus costs. Trader Joe’s wants roughly $2 million for defending the claims it won, applied as an offset against any fee award to the participants’ side. It isn’t asking individual employees to write a check. Both sides have appealed the judgment, and the competing fee requests remain pending. The legal bill has become a substantial dispute of its own.
Retirement Plans (13)
PLANSPONSOR covers the House’s 295 to 128 vote to extend collective investment trusts to 403(b) plans, the pooled vehicles long available in 401(k) menus. The bill would change the securities laws so plans serving teachers, nonprofit workers and hospital employees can use them. The Senate has not acted.
Diana Britton’s report on the 403(b) collective investment trust bill adds the market history behind the debate, the K-12 teacher plans where high-cost annuity sales drew years of scrutiny and where lower-cost pooled vehicles have been unavailable.
PLANSPONSOR reports the 2027 cost-of-living adjustments, the deferral limit rising to $25,500, the age-50 catch-up to $8,500 and the catch-up for workers aged 60 to 63 to $11,750, with the separate health and welfare adjustments for the same plan year noted alongside. The IRA limit holds at $7,500.
Andy Stonehouse’s report carries a full reference table of the 2027 limits, 11 rows of plan figures plus the IRA and SIMPLE amounts and the income phase-out ranges. The $1,000 deferral increase comes with higher catch-up limits for workers 50 and older, while the IRA limit stays at $7,500.
Ferenczy pairs the updated limits with reminders about the prior-year compensation used to identify highly compensated employees and the separate wage test for mandatory Roth catch-up contributions. The alert also compares the limits with prior years, helping administrators distinguish the published limit from the year’s compensation used to apply it.
CAPTRUST’s chart lays out the 2027 limits beside the prior four years, 11 rows from the deferral limit through the compensation and HCE thresholds, sourced to Notice 2026-66. The five-year view is the quick answer to how much each limit has moved.
PLANSPONSOR covers the Prudential paper by David Blanchett and Phil Waldeck proposing that defined contribution plans default part of participants’ savings into guaranteed income with the right to opt out, a reversal window among the proposed design features and a modeled 20% allocation illustrating the approach. The paper aims at savings that are not structured to produce steady income in retirement.
Schroders surveyed 1,500 US investors aged 30 to 79 in the spring and found 52% interested in private assets inside their retirement plans, up from 45% a year earlier. About half of the interested group would allocate under 10%. Self-reported comfort is not fiduciary diligence, and the investment-selection rule that would frame these menus remains under review, so the survey measures appetite, not availability.
Jacob Eigner argues that the target-date fund’s birth-year buckets have not kept pace with what plans now know about participants, longevity and spending, and that defaults should use that data. He is equally skeptical of personalization fees that outrun demonstrated value, pressing for innovation in the default itself.
Mayer Brown summarizes the SEC’s fiscal 2027 examination priorities, retirement rollover advice, older investors, illiquid and private investments, conflicts of interest and vendor cybersecurity among them. The priorities create no new obligations, but they describe where the examiners of plan advisers and recordkeepers’ affiliates will be looking.
In a survey of 2,002 US adults sponsored by L-Nutra, 72% said they would prefer fewer, healthier years to a longer retirement, and 82% said they would accept a hypothetical pay cut or retirement delay for more healthy years. The survey measures stated preferences about healthspan, not plan behavior or savings outcomes.
Morningstar’s Michael Allen distinguishes AI that explains from AI that decides, and describes the guardrails his team uses for retirement applications, traceability of outputs, testing against known answers and a human who stays responsible for the result.
Health & Welfare (10)
Haynes Boone distills the PBM fee-disclosure rule for large self-insured plans. The detailed requirements apply to plan years beginning on or after July 1, 2027, calendar 2028 for most plans. Renewal disclosures arrive at least 90 days ahead, fee reports run semiannually, and plans hold annual audit rights. The firm reads the rule as a reason to open PBM and consultant agreements now.
The pharmacy benefit managers’ trade association responded to the disclosure rule the day it was released. PCMA’s David Marin argues the rule duplicates disclosure obligations that already exist in contracts and other law, says the added reporting burden falls hardest on smaller PBMs competing for plan business, and questions the Labor Department’s authority to impose it. The group says it will evaluate pathways to address its concerns, language short of announcing a suit.
PLANSPONSOR reports EBRI’s estimate that surprise-billing arbitration awards closed in 2025 represent $8.39 billion in payment obligations beyond plans’ initial payments, after accounting for patient cost sharing, roughly 0.625% of the $1.34 trillion employers spend on health coverage. The figure is an estimate of additional amounts owed on 2.56 million disputes, not measured premium growth, and payment of individual awards is assumed rather than verified.
HHS’s Office for Civil Rights settled with a genetic testing and clinical genomics provider for $700,000 after a 2020 phishing breach affecting about 225,370 people, with a two-year corrective action plan requiring a risk assessment, terminated access for departed workers and unique user IDs. For employer health plans, the enforcement pattern keeps pointing at the same basics, risk analysis and access control.
An outside audit UnitedHealth commissioned reviewed how UnitedHealthcare develops the medical policies behind coverage decisions, sampling nine policies and finding documentation gaps, criteria in need of updating and uneven expert vetting. The audit examined policy development, not how the criteria are applied to actual claims, and its scope ran to government programs rather than employer-plan denial rates.
Holland & Knight’s post-election health policy outlook covers the new committee leadership and the policy areas it expects to move, pharmacy benefit manager reform, 340B, Medicare Advantage oversight, telehealth and health AI. For employer plans, the PBM and surprise-billing discussions concern rules plans administer directly, and the piece tracks the HSA and ICHRA proposals that would change plan design.
Illinois and Philadelphia have enacted workplace menopause measures, and Lee Hafner reports most employers have not caught up. In an NFP survey of 1,000 employers, 54% were unaware of the laws while 34% are open to adding support within five years. SHRM finds about 27% of employers offer any menopause benefit today. The design advice in the piece starts small, inventory what current benefits already cover, communicate it, and let staff feedback shape additions before buying new point solutions.
OPM is extending the suspension of applications for the Federal Long Term Care Insurance Program for 24 months beginning December 19, 2026, citing a contracting long-term care market and premium instability. Current enrollees keep their coverage, eligibility and claims reimbursement. No new applications or coverage increases will be accepted. The program covers the federal workforce, and the suspension is a signal about the group long-term care market generally.
The Defense Department published TRICARE’s 2027 cost-shares, enrollment fees and catastrophic caps, effective January 1, 2027, with a 3.6% retiree cost-of-living adjustment running through the retiree fee schedule. A retired Prime enrollee pays $396 a year in Group A and $480 in Group B, and a retiree family in Select Group B pays $1,233.96. The retiree catastrophic cap runs $3,000 in Prime Group A against $4,802 in Group B, with the notice’s tables carrying the full fee, deductible and copay schedules.
Lee Hafner profiles BAiO, whose founder describes a platform that reads wearables, records and photo inputs to nudge individual health decisions, with incentives from premium credits to HSA dollars, and de-identified aggregates for employers. The claims-avoidance case rests on the vendor’s own illustrations rather than an independent outcomes study.
Leave & Time Off (3)
San Diego’s Ordinance 22151, signed October 30 and effective November 29, revises the city’s paid sick and safe time rules toward the state scheme. The revisions add a designated-person use category and require reinstatement of unused balances when an employee returns within a year. Employers may cap annual use at 40 hours or five days and accrual at 80 hours or ten days, in each case whichever is greater. Littler reads the practical change for employers already complying with state law as mostly minimal, with enforcement provisions strengthened.
In In re McDevitt, decided October 29, New Jersey’s Appellate Division held that USERRA sets a federal floor, not a ceiling, and that state law protected a public employee’s military leave beyond USERRA’s five-year mark on these facts. Ogletree’s caution for multistate employers is that military-leave obligations can exceed the federal statute. The decision is not a holding that leave is unlimited.
Fisher Phillips surveys what Texas’s new political alignment could put in play for employers. Paid family leave and safe-leave proposals lead the list, with minimum wage measures, workplace heat protections and noncompete limits behind them. All of it is prospective, proposals for coming sessions rather than enacted obligations.
Court Decisions & Case Commentary (8)
After a trial that produced a $715,264 surcharge plus $471,957 in interest on the recordkeeping-fee claim while the plan prevailed on the forfeiture and investment theories, both sides filed fee motions on November 10. Plaintiffs seek $2,930,470 in fees, a 1.25 times multiplier on their lodestar, and $66,030.45 in costs. Trader Joe’s seeks $2,024,817, alternatively $2,864,147, plus $10,636.13 in costs as an offset against any award to plaintiffs rather than a bill to participants. Both sides have appealed the underlying judgment. The motions frame what a mixed ERISA trial result is worth in fees. The competing fee requests remain pending.
A proposed $3.175 million settlement would resolve Barker v. J.B. Hunt, the tobacco-surcharge suit covering roughly 25,500 plan participants who paid the surcharges from June 2020 forward. Each participant’s share would be proportional to the surcharges they paid. The papers also seek fees and costs of up to a third, $7,500 service awards and review by an independent fiduciary. The parties are seeking preliminary approval.
In the Waffle House tobacco-surcharge suit in Atlanta, the plaintiff moved November 11 for leave to amend, dropping the counts the company’s arbitration motion targets while keeping planwide fiduciary-breach claims and adding the plan committee as a defendant. The defense seeks individual arbitration and a stay. The competing filings put the familiar question, whether plan-level relief can proceed outside individual arbitration, in front of the court, with no ruling yet on either motion.
SpecialtyCare and affiliated providers sued Anthem in New Hampshire on November 11, alleging $138,953 in independent dispute resolution awards remain unpaid and pleading six alternative routes to collect, from confirmation of the awards and a No Surprises Act private action to ERISA benefit and enforcement claims. The complaint acknowledges disagreement among courts over how providers can enforce these awards. The providers are seeking payment of awards already issued. For plans and administrators, it tests what happens after an IDR award goes unpaid.
In a nonprecedential opinion, the Third Circuit vacated a refusal to enforce an arbitrator’s award requiring PPL to reimburse an IBEW Local 1600 member $50 for a doctor’s note, holding the arbitrator rationally read the contract’s government-regulation clause to incorporate Pennsylvania’s Medical Pay Law. The point for benefits administration is arbitral deference on contract interpretation, not a new reimbursement mandate.
A widow pursuing her late husband’s life-insurance benefits in Richards v. LifePoint Health Welfare Benefits Plan won limited discovery on November 6 into how the plan handled comparable claims, records that bear on whether the insurer applied the plan’s terms to her claim the way it applied them to others. The court applied Tennessee law under the plan’s choice-of-law clause, defeating the Texas anti-discretionary-clause theory and dismissing that count.
Jackson Lewis analyzes the Eleventh Circuit’s en banc Bolton decision, which overruled decades of circuit precedent requiring participants to exhaust plan procedures before bringing statutory ERISA claims, in a case over a $92 million ESOP loan. The holding reaches statutory claims only and leaves the existing exhaustion rules for benefit-denial claims untouched. It also leaves open whether plan terms can require exhaustion of statutory claims. The language in this plan was permissive.
Proskauer covers Schmidt v. City of Pasadena, where the Ninth Circuit held the PREP Act immunized the city against an employee’s challenge to the COVID-19 testing and masking conditions attached to his religious exemption. The published opinion ties immunity to covered persons administering covered countermeasures and to injuries causally related to them, rather than creating a blanket shield for every pandemic policy, and it affirmed the reconsideration, recusal and sanctions rulings below.
Executive Compensation (3)
In Huset v. EIS Ultimate Holding, decided November 5, the Colorado Court of Appeals held that attempting to enforce a void noncompete after the 2022 statute’s effective date exposes an employer to penalties even though the agreement predates the statute. The covenant was attached to incentive units, the point where executive compensation plans meet state noncompete law. The holding turns on enforcement conduct after the effective date, not on a rule against all covenants.
New SEC staff interpretations issued October 15 address when compensatory equity awards need Securities Act registration. Two positions carry the most practical weight. Assumed awards held by former employees can be covered under Form S-8 and Rule 701, and registration timing for restricted stock and RSUs is measured at vesting when the holder was eligible at grant. The guidance also reaches pre-IPO awards and reuse of shares recovered through forfeiture. For 401(k) plans, S-8 registration fees reach only employee contributions and matching money invested in employer securities. The positions are staff interpretations rather than rules.
Troutman’s podcast, with a published transcript, reviews the Section 409A ground that year-end planning touches. Two timing rules matter for year-end planning. Deferral elections generally must be in place before the year the compensation is earned, which is what makes December the deadline for 2027 elections. And changing an election afterward generally requires acting at least 12 months before the scheduled payment date and pushing the payment out at least five years. The episode also covers common traps in equity awards, corporate transactions and plan terminations. It is a primer on existing rules, not new guidance.
Also Noteworthy (2)
Mayer Brown’s contracting framework for agentic AI, role allocation, least-privilege access, transparent data rights, human oversight, logging and liability terms, is written for enterprise deals generally. The same checklist fits benefits-administration vendors adopting AI agents, though the piece itself does not take up benefits arrangements.
IFEBP’s Word on Benefits makes the case that rising costs, changing regulation and growing employee expectations call for dedicated benefits professionals rather than HR generalists, and sketches the career paths into the field. The piece closes on the foundation’s CEBS credential and programs as the preparation route.
Correction. The November 12 issue incorrectly identified Phil Waldeck, coauthor of Prudential’s Automatic Lifetime Income paper, as Dylan Waldeck. The web version has been corrected.