BENEFITS DIGEST

Primary sources. Practical insight. Every weekday.

A publication of The Inner Firm

Tuesday, August 18, 2026

№ 33

29 items · ~7 min read

Regulatory & Guidance (2)·Court Decisions (2)·Retirement Plans (14)·Health & Welfare (5)·Case Commentary (6)

The One Thing

How do you prove a 401(k) fund was imprudent? For years the standard defense has been that a plaintiff must point to a nearly identical fund that did better, and if they can't, case over. This week two courts said not so fast. The Eleventh Circuit revived the lawsuit over Royal Caribbean's target-date funds in a published opinion, holding that qualitative evidence, like a fund's unpopularity and poor analyst ratings, can do the job without an apples-to-apples comparator. And a Minnesota judge let target-date claims against 3M go forward after finding Fidelity's Freedom funds a fair comparison. If your plan committee has been counting on the benchmark defense, this is the week to talk it through with your ERISA advisors.

Regulatory & Guidance (2)

DOL Semiannual Regulatory Agenda
Department of Labor · Federal Register 2026-08-14

DOL's semiannual regulatory agenda, where EBSA rulemakings get sequenced. The notable thing is how empty it is: the EBSA section carries exactly one entry, the IDR Operations rule, and that rule was already finalized on June 4. In other words, EBSA currently has no pending rulemaking on the public agenda at all.

Coming Soon: IDR Gateway User Sign-Up
CMS 2026-08-14

The federal IDR process moves from single-use web forms to a centralized IDR Gateway late this year, with account registration opening September 15. Practical note for sponsors: a plan using a TPA does not register itself, but should confirm before September 15 that its TPA holds the administrator role.

Court Decisions (2)

Ann Johnson v. Russell Investments Trust Company
Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit 2026-08-17

In a published opinion, the Eleventh Circuit reversed summary judgment for Royal Caribbean in the imprudence suit over its proprietary Russell target-date funds, holding that a plaintiff need not identify an apples-to-apples comparator to establish objective imprudence in every case. Qualitative evidence such as a fund's unpopularity and negative analyst ratings can carry the point, and a fund's own custom benchmark is not automatically the only proper measuring stick when the plaintiff's theory is that the benchmark's built-in features are what made the fund imprudent.

Cunningham v. Cornell University
U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York 2026-08-06

On remand from the Supreme Court, Judge Castel split the jury question in the surviving prohibited-transaction claim: the request that fiduciaries make good the plan's losses goes to a jury, because, in the court's words, it is "a 'make good' remedy, and hence legal in nature, to which the plaintiffs are entitled to a jury," while the equitable relief, including removal of fiduciaries, an accounting, and reformation, will be tried by the bench. The order's conclusion reads as a flat denial of Cornell's motion, but the body grants it in part. Both halves matter to anyone tracking whether ERISA fiduciary claims get juries.

Retirement Plans (14)

Part of 3M ERISA Suit Survives After Judge Finds Fidelity Funds Fit as Benchmark
PLANSPONSOR 2026-08-17

A Minnesota federal judge allowed target-date imprudence and self-dealing claims against 3M to proceed after finding the amended complaint's Fidelity Freedom fund comparison a meaningful benchmark, while narrowing other theories. The suit was dismissed this spring with leave to amend for exactly this deficiency, so the ruling shows what a benchmark allegation that works actually looks like.

Key Deadlines Set for Preapproved Defined Contribution Plans
Mercer · Law & Policy 2026-08-14

IRS Announcement 2026-15 gives employers using preapproved defined contribution plans until September 30, 2028 to adopt newly approved documents for the fourth remedial amendment cycle. Mercer maps the dates plan sponsors and document providers need on the calendar.

IRS Streamlines Private Letter Ruling Submission Process
NAPA Net Daily 2026-08-17

Plan sponsors seeking IRS sign-off on individual plan questions get a simpler road: new Form 15662 standardizes private letter ruling requests, pay.gov filing opens August 26, and paper submissions end September 4. Worth knowing before your next plan design question needs a ruling.

Trump Account Rules Ease Path as Small Employers Face Slow Start
Bloomberg Law 2026-08-17

Bloomberg Law reports early signals that small employers will be slow to add Trump Account contributions even as the proposed rules clear a path, with practitioners pointing to an administrative load that outweighs the $2,500 draw for many.

Health & Welfare (5)

Illinois Introduces Workplace Protections for Menopause-Related Conditions
LittlerDeadline 2026-08-17

Illinois amended its Human Rights Act on August 7 to establish workplace protections for employees experiencing menopause-related conditions, effective January 1, 2027, and reaching employers with a single Illinois employee. Littler on the compliance build-out between now and the effective date.

Illinois' Menopause Equity and Care Act Expands Employment Protections
Jackson Lewis · via JD SupraDeadline 2026-08-12

Jackson Lewis on the same statute from the accommodation side: Illinois joins Rhode Island and Philadelphia in making menopause-related conditions a protected status, and employers should review handbooks, leave policies, and benefit designs before the January effective date.

Why It's Time to Step Up Menopause Support
Employee Benefit News 2026-08-17

The benefits-design case: menopause-related productivity loss costs U.S. employers an estimated $1.8 billion annually while only 18 percent treat it as a material benefits issue. The new state laws will force the gap onto agendas.

Roundup of Selected State Health Developments, Second-Quarter 2026
Mercer · Law & Policy 2026-08-14

Mercer's quarterly state survey: Virginia enacted both paid family and medical leave and paid sick and safe leave, several states passed major PBM laws including a Tennessee statute challenged in court the day it took effect, and Alabama, Georgia, and Texas legislated on AI use in benefits.

Case Commentary (6)

Schuman v. Microchip: $13 Million Severance Settlement Wins Preliminary Approval
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California · via Bloomberg Law 2026-08-03

Judge Gilliam granted preliminary approval of a $13 million settlement resolving ERISA fiduciary-breach and benefit-denial claims by 220 former Atmel employees over severance under the Atmel U.S. Severance Guarantee Benefit Program: $9.5 million to the class plus $3.5 million in fees, reported to deliver 80 to 100 percent of unpaid severance with interest.

Meaningful Benchmarks Bench TDF Suite Suit
NAPA Net Daily 2026-08-17

The counterpoint to the 3M ruling, from the same Minnesota federal court: in Scholin v. Digi-Key, Judge Bryan dismissed a challenge to American Century target-date funds because the complaint never explained why its comparator funds were comparable, calling their composition a mystery. Together the two rulings sketch the line between benchmark allegations that survive and ones that don't.

Has the Wave of Tobacco Premium Surcharge Suits Hit a Wall?
Groom Law Group 2026-08-17

Groom surveys the tobacco-surcharge docket after the trio of July decisions favoring employers, including the Target and Campbell Soup dismissals covered here this week, and asks whether the 75-case wave has crested or is merely regrouping.

Ninth Circuit Vacates Summary Judgment for Pension Plan Fiduciaries, Directing Reassessment of Prudence Under Intel's Prospective-Methods Standard
Roberts Disability Law 2026-08-17

In Klawonn v. Motion Picture Industry Pension Plans, the Ninth Circuit vacated summary judgment for the fiduciaries and sent the case back for evaluation under Anderson v. Intel's prospective-methods standard: prudence is judged by the methods fiduciaries employed, not by whether underperformance was substantial and consistent.